Another example of Judicial Decisions from Judges who operate outside their fields of expertise
Judge Toogood Doesn’t Recognize Reasons Rebuttal.
“The appellant commissioned a second report from Mr Joy. This was prepared by Mr Joy in response to Mr Young’s affidavit, the submissions of counsel for Maritime New Zealand in opposition to the rehearing application, and Judge Davis’s reserved judgment declining the application for a rehearing. It comprises a purported rebuttal of Mr Young’s affidavit, essentially on a paragraph-by-paragraph basis.”
Bolton writes a Submission Appealing this distorted Judicial thinking …
“Julian Joy’s Report & affidavit is a full rebuttal, of Barry Young’s affidavit & evidence, in the interests of clarifying the issues and assisting the Court.”
Note in addition to the above Submission …
Far from being a “purported rebuttal”, Julian Joy’s Reports are the most necessary response from Julian Joy to the nonsense promulgated by Barry Young aided & abetted by Maritime New Zealand, Ian Howden & Crown Law, Mark Davies. This is another glaring example of Judicial Decisions from Judges who are operating outside their fields of expertise. They know nothing of Nautical matters & yet have the temerity to criticize Julian Joy, a Navigational Expert with impeccable qualifications who is justifiably concerned that Barry Young, a member of the same fraternity has brought his Navigational profession into disrepute.
The two men were, at the time, employed as Lecturers at the same Auckland Maritime Nautical School.
How Barry Young could discredit his profession in such a dishonest way & still retain his employment raises concerns about the profession’s willingness to allow such a travesty of Justice to be publically demonstrated to the extent an innocent skipper will be prosecuted to satisfy the Waterfront Vigilate-ism evident in this case.
Both men were swearing to abide by an Expert Witness’s Code of Conduct with their prime responsibility to be of assistance to the Court. Barry Young chose to sell his soul as a Hired Gun without integrity, acting as an advocate to further the unwarranted claim presented by Maritime New Zealand.
Link for Seeing, Signing & Sharing Petition –