Preparation For Appeal Of Decision By Judge Davis.

Rule 22 wasn't applicable in this situation - there was to be a safe crossing without risk of collision

Preparation For Appeal Of Decision By Judge Davis.
Each Paragraph from Judge Davis’s decision is followed by correction
Para 12 : Onus & standard of proof – It is my duty to find the charges have not been proved beyond reasonable doubt ….
“The special circumstances of this situational ambiguity give rise to complexity of legal interpretation & application regarding Crossing safely ahead of a ferry on a regular run.”
Para 13 : The onus of proving the charge rests with the informant….
“The informant has an ulterior motive in proceeding with an unwarranted prosecution
using Colregs in a punitive manner, employing their expert witness as a “Hired Gun””
Para 14 : Maritime Rules. A comprehensive code of Rules (part 22) has been developed to govern situations where collisions may be apparent….
“Note that for the Rule to be applicable, there must be a “risk of collision” – no risk, no need to apply Rule 22 which is not a complete & comprehensive code of navigation – the ordinary precaution of prudent seamanship as defined by custom & professional courtesy are still required.”
Para 15 : The important point about Rule 22.7(1) is that if there is any doubt ….
“In this situation there was no doubt that each would pass clear of the other – the ferry passing astern of Classique, starboard to starboard.”
Para 16 : Rule 22.8 sets out the action required to be undertaken to avoid collision….
“This applies to the Stand-on vessel at a later stage when its unilateral avoidance may be required in the event the other vessel has not taken appropriate action. Not applicable in this case.”
Para 17 : Rule 22.15 Crossing Situation – crossing so as to involve risk of collision….
“This rule was not applicable in this situation where there was to be a safe crossing without risk of collision.”
Link for Seeing, Signing & Sharing Petition – http://maritimenz.com/AnnulConvictionGainedByAbuseOfCourtProcess

Diagram of the situation before Judge Davis. It shows the incremental turning of Seaway towards the path of Classique reducing the eventual passing clearance – in violation of Maritime Collision Regulations
Preparation For Appeal Of Decision By Judge Davis.

Preparation For Appeal Of Decision By Judge Davis.

Website Pin Facebook Twitter Myspace Friendfeed Technorati del.icio.us Digg Google StumbleUpon Premium Responsive

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

CommentLuv badge